New provisions on supervisory board under Polish Commercial Companies Code

Vydáno: 38 minút čítania

PINIOR, P.: New provisions on supervisory board under Polish Commercial Companies Code. Právny obzor, 105, 2022, special issue, pp. 44-59

https://doi.org/10.31577/pravnyobzor.specialissue.2022.04

New provisions on supervisory board under Polish Commercial Companies Code. The mandatory supervisory board is obliged to supervise the joint-stock company under Polish law. Supervision over the company’s activities in all aspects of its business is one of the most crucial elements in the corporate structure. This paper presents the new supervisory instruments in joint-stock companies and their assessment. The latest amendment to the Commercial Companies Code allows, among others, for the nomination of a supervisory board advisor, broader access to information, the appointment of committees, and the approval of transactions with related entities. Additionally, it aims to describe the impact of new provisions on the liability of the supervisory board  members.

Keywords: supervisory board, advisor, committee, liability

Introduction
With the amendment to the Polish Commercial Companies Code 1) adopted by the Act of 9 February 2022 2) , the legislature introduced new supervisory instruments in the private limited company, the simple joint-stock company, and the joint-stock company. Moreover, the duties of loyalty and due care, and the business judgment rule were introduced in both types of companies.
This paper aims to present the new provisions on the joint-stock company as these involve a complete regulation in this respect. Essentially, the supervisory body is not mandatory in all private limited companies 3) , and there is a choice between a monistic and dualistic system in simple joint-stock companies 4) . Additionally, some of the new instruments, for example, the provisions on supervisory board advisor in a private limited company, must be applied exclusively if the articles of association so provide (the opt-in system); some issues have been regulated only in joint-stock companies (e. g. the obligation of the management board to furnish the supervisory board with information).
Firstly, this paper presents the new supervisory instruments along with their assessment, and secondly, the impact of those provisions on the liability of the board members concerning the duty of loyalty and due care, and the business judgment rule.
 
1. Company supervision
 
1.1 Overall powers of the supervisory board
The supervisory board of a joint-stock company plays a pivotal role in the corporate supervisory system. Under the provision of Art. 382 § 1 CCC, the supervisory board exercises permanent supervision over the company's activities in all aspects of its business. The competence allows for the influence of the supervisory board in joint-stock companies over the management board (appointment, removal, suspension of the management board, the power of representation in contracts and disputes with the management board, settling the remuneration of the management board members, giving consent for company operations where the law or the company's by-laws so provide). The powers of the supervisory board also include reviewing the financial statements and the report of the management board in terms of their compliance with the books, documents, and facts, reviewing the proposals of the management board concerning the distribution of profits or coverage of losses and drawing up and submitting to the general meeting an annual written report for the previous financial year (report of the supervisory board).
Additional powers may result from other provisions, in particular from the Act of 29 July 2005 on Public Offering, Conditions Governing the Introduction of Financial Instruments to Organized Trading and Listed Companies 5) . In listed companies, pursuant to Art. 90g sec. 1 POA, the supervisory board of a company draws up an annual remuneration report presenting a comprehensive review of remuneration, including all benefits, regardless of their form, received by individual members of the management board and supervisory board in the last financial year. Moreover, under Art. 90i sec. 3 POA, the conclusion of a significant transaction requires the consent of the company's supervisory board (related-party transactions).
The new provisions introduced the possibility to nominate a supervisory board advisor, linked with the right to represent the company in a contract with the advisor, along with the right to determine the remuneration for the advisory activity. Further, the approval of transactions with a dominant company, a dependent company, or an associated company is now introduced. Apart from the said powers, the manner of exercising supervision was changed, including the right to information, document inspection, and supervision by nominated supervisory committees. Finally, regardless of the amendment to the supervisory system, the duty of loyalty and due care of the board members, the duty of confidentiality, together with the business judgment rule, were incorporated.
 
1.2 Nominating a supervisory board advisor
Pursuant to Art. 3821 CCC, the supervisory board may adopt a resolution on examining